Weekend Update

Marina Lake from Oil Well Trail, Presque Isle State Park

Dateline: 27 November 2021

There’d be a “Winter is coming…,” Game of Thrones joke in here somewhere, but it’s apparently too late for Erie. (Rain/cold on Thanksgiving, light snow/heavy wind/cold Friday, overcast/cold Saturday, and steady snow Sunday.) Most of the staff’s relocated to our sister site’s field station outside Oaxaca, Mexico (must be nice), leaving just a skeleton crew in Pennsylvania. Nevertheless, Birding, PI.com stands ready to marshal resources to keep you informed of birding ‘comings and goings’ at Presque Isle State Park, regardless of the season (!)

The area to the northwest of Marina Lake (Canoe Portage Trail, Duck Pond Trail, and Gas Well Trail) hadn’t been covered recently, so a team was dispatched Saturday for a comprehensive survey. Trail conditions:

Gas Well Trail: very muddy in spots, generally passable

Canoe Portage Trail: good condition

Duck Pond Trail (by Duck Pond): flooded and impassable

Duck Pond Trail (east of Canoe Portage Trail): very muddy

Duck Pond Trail (west of Canoe Portage Trail): muddy in spots but ok

Generally the area was quiet, except for an exciting sighting – and we’re going out on a limb here – of what appeared to be a Red-shouldered Hawk. It swooped across the Duck Pond Trail, perched for several minutes, then flew off to neighboring trees. Pursuit continued through the underbrush, hampered by eventually running out of land.

Red-shouldered Hawk, juvenile (only slightly cropped @ 500mm)

Cropped/zoomed for detail

Factors in favor of this as a Red-shouldered Hawk:

  • Banded, long tail (vs. Red-tailed Hawks having a more obviously red and shorter tail)
  • Dark color with white ‘scallops’ on back
  • ‘Tear drop-shaped’ (?) markings on breast (Red-tailed Hawks generally have a different pattern)
  • White eyebrow
  • Broad-shouldered Hawks (which may look similar) migrate south, whereas Red-shouldered Hawks are known for staying put in the Northeast; they also inhabit forests, as was the case here. In comparison, Red-tailed Hawks, for example, tend to perch above open areas, in our experience.
  • Looks like pictures of Red-shouldered Hawk juveniles on the Internet, which is never wrong.
It’s all so confusing
Strategic petroleum reserve
Downy Woodpecker, Canoe Portage Trail
GBH and Mallards (M & F), Duck Pond
GBH, Duck Pond
Canadian Geese, Short Pond
Ring-necked Ducks, Short Pond
Hooded Mergansers (F) and Geese, Short Pond
Female Hooded Mergansers
Long shot of Ring-necked Ducks (M & F), on left, and Hooded Mergansers (M & F), on middle/right, Long Pond
Hooded Mergansers, Long Pond
Mallards I, Long Pond
Mallards II, Long Pond
Mallards III, Long Pond
Mallards IV, Long Pond Trail. Ok, not a Mallard. (White-throated Sparrow.)
Sparrow, by Long Pond
White-throated Sparrow, by Long Pond
Golden-crowned Kinglet, near Thompson Bay
Female or immature Hooded Mergansers?