Blurry Birds Analysis

Time for recent long-distance observations at Gull Point. With a camera + long lens (most shots below @ 1200mm), lots of heat shimmer on a warm day = blurry birds. Nevertheless, a useful tool for interesting bird ID’s/sightings.

‘Entrance’ to outer Gull Point

First up, terns! The most common tern @ Presque Isle State Park is Caspian Tern, the world’s largest tern species. Which is confusing, esp. for this post, because there’s a species actually called Common Tern. (Another awful/generic bird name.) And speaking of both, here’s a shot of mixed Caspian Tern, Common Tern, and what might be a juvenile Bonaparte’s Gull (?) on the lower right:

Mixed terns

Let’s discuss this ID. Caspian Terns: relatively large, distinctive tern black cap, chunky/dagger-like red-orange bill. In the annotated shot below, Caspian Terns @ “A.” Best way to ID other tern species generally, if possible, is based on size. Note the terns at “B” – similar looking overall (black cap, pointy red or orange bill) but much smaller. Could be any of several smaller tern species, but at Presque Isle the non-rare options* would be Common Tern or Forster’s Tern. Meaning, start there for an ID analysis.

Annotated terns

Both Common Tern and Forster’s Tern have a forked tail, so this shot is not terribly helpful:

Is an annotated shot to point out the forked tail really necessary?

OTOH, Common Tern typically has a gray belly and a thinner, reddish, black-tipped bill, whereas Forster’s = white belly and heavier, orange-ish, black-tipped bill.

Common Tern in flight?

In the annotated shot below, note what appears to be a gray belly at “A.” The bill at “B” appears orange-ish, but is very thin and straight:

Annotated tern features

Another factor: wing colouration. Common Tern has darker gray wings outlined by black at the tips, mostly visible in flight:

In this annotation, note the black-looking wing tip region at “A,” and again, the gray belly at “B:”

Another view of dark wing tips:

And another interesting clue, this time the bird @ lower right:

In the following annotation, note the colouration pointed to by the arrow. As per the experts, “Immatures and nonbreeding adults have a distinctive black bar on the leading edge of the wing, known as a carpal bar.”

So, very possibly an immature Common Tern. Another view:

In conclusion, small size, consistent bill, gray belly, dark wing tip regions, + possible juvenile = positive ID for Common Tern!


Moving on, a much easier ID of a blurry but still cute adult Piping Plover:

Note the single narrow breast band, thin black head band, and overall relatively light face/head colouration:

Semipalmated Plover (the next likeliest species at this location) would be overall larger, overall darker, & with a much darker overall face/head.


Blurry Spotted Sandpiper

Another easier ID, it’s a blurry but great Black-bellied Plover:

Factors for this ID: relatively large, + black belly, + lacks the black top-of-head patch of an American Golden-Plover (which would be rare for this location/time anyway).


Enough long-distance, time for some ‘bonus’ not-as-blurry birds:

Osprey I
Probably Song Sparrow
Osprey II
Departing Semipalmated Plover x3

And as if this post isn’t long enough already, a great sequence of American Kestrel @ flying & landing:

This is one of the several Gull Point outwards-facing “Don’t moor within 100 yards of shore” (or something like that) warning signs for boaters, reflecting the protected nesting season status:

* Tip: to see the mostly likely candidates for the date/location in question, pull up the eBird checklist, which defaults to “non-rare.” For Gull Point in May, the most common tern options are Common, Forster’s, & Caspian. (Plenty of other ways to utilize eBird in this regard, such as looking at species reporting bar charts for recent years; here, 2023 reporting shows more reportings of Caspian and Common Terns in May, but fewer Forster’s.)


Coming soon, very blue and purple birds!

Gull Pt. Warblers

Dateline: 18 May 2024

Somehow finagled quick turnaround from the BirdingPI.com photo editing team on these shots from yesterday at Presque Isle State Park along the Gull Point Trail in the afternoon. Guess everyone has warbler fever!

Yellow Warbler by Gull Point Trail trailhead

Conditions here and in the Pine Tree Trail area yesterday were rather excellent. Most ‘common’ warbler species spotted except Palm & Black-throated Blue. Even an unprecedented sighting (i.e., two days in a row) of amazing male Canada Warbler, in the willow thickets close to outer Gull Point:

Canada Warbler (m)
Yellow Warbler, rear view
Yellow Warbler @ singing mode in honeysuckle bush
Cape May Warbler

Big news was a significant uptick in Bay-breasted Warbler sightings, like this (probably) lovely female:

Bay-breasted Warbler (f)

(Seems in past year the Bay-breasted Warblers passed through much earlier = some worry it was going to be a light year for this lovely species.)

More Bay-breasted Warbler:


Magnolia Warbler I
Another shot of Bay-breasted Warbler
Magnolia Warbler II
American Redstart (m)
Magnolia Warbler III
Bay-breasted Warbler (m)
American Redstart (f)
Another view of American Redstart (m)

Meanwhile, PM shorebird activity on the Point was fairly light. (Yellowlegs, Dunlin, etc.)


Coming up soon, lots of warblers on the Pine Tree Trail!

Oh, Canada!

The amazing/beautiful Canada Warbler: uncommon enough at Presque Isle State Park for any sighting to be a special occasion. Throw in a few minutes of a mostly clear view at eye level the other morning along the Duck Pond Trail, and it’s warbler portraiture gold.

Canada Warbler (m)

Bonus action/fly-catching shot:


[Editor’s note: “Bird portraiture:” a bird perched on a branch, standing on ground, or floating in water, not engaged in any particular activity, where the anatomical, etc. features are clear for conveying a sense of species ID.]

Improbably Yellow Birds, etc.

So much bird excitement at Presque Isle State Park, running very late on today’s post. (“Spoiler alert:” Canada Warbler!) Ahead of the weekend, lots of ongoing American Robin, Common Grackle, Red-winged Blackbird, Gray Catbird!, Yellow Warbler, Song Sparrow, etc. activity. So much so, hard to keep an eye out for the less common offerings. Warbler activity overall remains good, but erratic. Same with shorebirds, e.g., Semipalmated, Piping, and Black-bellied Plover sighted at Gull Point recently, otherwise fairly quiet other than Spotted Sandpiper.

American Goldfinch (m), lovely wing feather view

More recent sightings forthcoming; here’s Leo’s Landing @ early morning (e.g., 7AM) on Global Big Day last Saturday.

GBH
Song Sparrow
American Goldfinch (m) front view
Baltimore Oriole (f or juvenile) w/ wild mustard
More Goldfinch
GBH w/ backlit bill
Yellow Warbler (m)
Mallard (m)
#more_finch
More GBH
Yellow, hello!
Preening
More Warbler
More GBH preening
Very yellow
Bald Eagles @ tree
A yellow rear view
Still more GBH
Yellow Warbler duo
Eagles departing
Another Goldfinch
More Song Sparrow
Gray Catbird!
Baltimore Oriole (m) on branch
The Catbird! disapproves

“Bird of the outing,” beautiful male Blackpoll Warbler:


The Grackle

Scott @ Sunset

Recent photographs from Presque Isle-adjacent Scott Park in Millcreek Twp (“Gateway to Presque Isle”), right around sunset:

Cedar Waxwing
Ruby-throated Hummingbird (m)
Waxwing II
Gray Catbird!
Waxwing III
Another view of Ruby-throated Hummingbird
Waxwing IV

This next/lengthy sequence captures (as best possible for still photos) a rather amazing behavior – three Cedar Waxwing in a tree, passing a small piece of vegetative matter (seed pod?) back and forth for at least 5 minutes:

Per Internet sources, this is probably social behavior, e.g., passing food between birds as a social activity or so each bird has a chance to eat. (Other option is mating behavior, which doesn’t seem applicable here.) Very cool to see!


Red-bellied Woodpecker
American Redstart (m)
The red belly

Big Day Goose Babies

Finally, it’s BirdingPI.com’s consensus staff favourite yearly post, Canada Goose babies! Yay! By the road at Sidewalk Trail east trailhead (by Misery Bay), Presque Isle State Park, last Saturday afternoon on Global Big Day, in light rain.

Very unusually, this brood consisted of at least 16 goslings. That’s a lot of baby geese! Typical numbers are 5-10, but occasionally possible for two broods to merge, which is probably what happened here.

Early May @ The Point

Still recovering from Global Big Day weekend, so it’s back to the previous weekend with shots from a hike out to Gull Point @ Presque Isle State Park.

KIF

Mostly overcast = photography/exposure conditions not great. Nevertheless, fun to see this Eastern Kingbird in action:

Twisting upside down to grab a bug mid-air

Least Flycatcher
Black-and-white Warbler

Following is a hoverfly (in genus Eristalis, exact species unknown) on what’s probably invasive Cypress Spurge (Euphorbia cyparissias), all over Presque Isle in sandy areas:


Red Admiral (Vanessa atalanta) on Cypress Spurge

Beautiful Dunlin @ outer Gull Point:


Probably Orange Sulphur butterfly (Colias eurytheme), on left, on Philadelphia Fleabane (Erigeron philadelphicus):


Barn Swallow trio
More butterfly
BSIF
More Orange Sulphur
Probably Cabbage White butterfly (Pieris rapae)

‘Bird of the day’ (or any day) was a surprise early sighting of Whimbrel:

Whimbrel (r) w/ Canada Geese (l)
Whimbrel in lagoon

According to the nice folks at eBird, this was the earliest recorded sighting of Whimbrel at this location (or maybe Erie Co. generally) by at least a couple weeks.

Whimbrel on rocky bay-side beach
OIF

More Whimbrel:


Based on dark head colouration, this appears to be Semipalmated Plover:

Uncropped view from observation platform
Cropped view of Semipalmated Plover

Unfortunately, the Whimbrel left soon hereafter, heading out easterly over Lake Erie:

WIF
Departing Whimbrel

[Editor’s note: “KIF” = Killdeer in flight, “BSIF” = Barn Swallow in flight, “OIF” = Osprey in flight, “WIF” = Whimbrel in flight. Note to staff: please stop using “…IF” – thank you.]

1 Bird

It was interesting weather at Presque Isle State Park for Global Big Day yesterday. ‘Interesting’ = mostly crappy, i.e., less than ideally conducive for productive and pleasant birding all day. … Mostly sunny (although windy/cool) until about 11AM, then light on/off rain, then moderate rain, then partial clearing by mid-afternoon, then moderate/heavy rain (+ sometimes very windy) late afternoon/evening as another front rolled through. Bird activity rather erratic, but lots to see!

Rain moving in to Presque Isle, late Saturday morning

Bird photography into thick brush or high into the tree canopy is hard enough. Just try it with an umbrella under rainy conditions on the Ridge Trail. Nevertheless, the suffering extra effort paid off, with this amazing Ovenbird, taken under rainy/overcast conditions close to where the Ridge Trail intersects the Sidewalk Trail at their east ends:

“Bird Watching Rule 14(a): the bird of the day is always Ovenbird, unless there’s an owl.” Johnson, Daniel & Matheson, Herbert. The Great Book of Bird Watching. 1st ed., HarperCollins, 1963.


Coming up soon, more Global Big Day!